Okay, this is awkward sorry for spamming… The solution was: I had a check field that was required, but HIDE option was set to NONE so form was trying to get me to check that field but it was hidden… After deleting it, now it works perfectly.
Thanks for posting this, I had the exact same issue. I do wish I could have required buttons for one submit button and then when that form is hidden, have the other submit button work for just the fields it is used for to collect information. I can’t create two forms because I distributed the form fields across a grid, and it’s not possible to nest forms.