Anyone have success with Form Sparrow for emails? I'm running into an annoying issue

Hi there!

To avoid the crappiness of the basic Webflow form delivery I was trying out Form Sparrow for the first time.
They’ve got decent documentation (specific to Webflow) and I’ve got it set up and working (delivering and redirecting nicely).

I’ve included the redirection in an HTML embed (working well) and I’ve followed the same thing for customizing the “replyto”… to get the email address the user submits in the form. I’ve tried using the “name” and “id” of that field and it’s not working. (shown in the link above)

<input type="hidden" name="_replyto" value="%Email-2">
<input type="text" name="_honey" value="" style="display:none">
<input type="hidden" name="_after" value="https://barbour-searson-jones-cash.webflow.io/email-confirmation">

Anyone have success with this implementation? Or see something glaringly obvious that I’m missing?

Alternatively, anyone have a recommendation for a cheap alternative? This is a super simple form that will not be getting that many submissions so I don’t want to invest in a high monthly fee.

Here is my site Read-Only: Webflow - Barbour Searson Jones Cash