It’s mostly working now. What is still not working is that if you type in the www subdomain, it’s not redirecting as it should to the bare domain, and it’s landing on a 404 page. Still perplexed about that one.
At any rate, for future googleers: here’s the configuration needed!
For a website using SSL and a “naked domain” (no www subdomain)
- Create a CNAME of root (@ or / or blank) to proxy-ssl.webflow.com
- Create an ANAME (a.k.a. Alias) or CNAME of
wwwto http://proxy-ssl.webflow.com
DO NOT use the A records it tells you to use! Neither the SSL nor the non-SSL A names! They’ll mess everything up.