Multiple sorting criteria for collections doesn't seem to work


I have a collection that I’m trying to sort by two criteria, one being a featured toggle switch and the second being a date in reverse chronological order:


So the featured sorting appears to be working fine, but the date sorting is weird. I see a bunch of entries from 2009/2008 and one random one from 2017, and then it appears to go to 2019, 2018, 2017…and so on in the correct order. It’s just those 2009/2008 dated ones and one 2017 that appear in the wrong order.

I checked the CMS items to make sure the dates weren’t off, and took a close look at the 2017 just b/c it seemed like the odd one of the group, but nothing seems off with it either.

Any thoughts?

Here is my site Read-Only: LINK
(how to share your site Read-Only link)